How does a 1031 exchange work? Deferring tax when you sell U.S. investment property (including for nonresidents and people who moved abroad)
When you sell U.S. real estate held for rental, investment or business use, a qualified intermediary holds the proceeds, you identify replacement property within 45 days and close within 180 days, and the capital gains tax and depreciation recapture are deferred. To defer all of it, buy at least as much, reinvest all the net proceeds and don't reduce your debt. Homes, flips and property outside the U.S. don't qualify.
- 45 days
- Identify the replacement property in a signed writing by midnight of day 45 after the sale closes; weekends and holidays don't extend it
- 180 days
- Receive the replacement property within 180 days, and no later than your return due date (with extensions), whichever comes first
- 3 / 200% / 95%
- Identify up to 3 properties of any value, or any number totaling no more than 200% of what you sold; beyond that, you must acquire 95% of the value identified
- 2 years
- In an exchange with a relative or related company, if either side sells within 2 years, the deferred gain generally becomes taxable
At a glance
- Deferral, not forgiveness. Since 2018 it covers only real property exchanged for real property held for business or investment. Your home and property held primarily for sale don't qualify, and U.S. and foreign real estate are not like-kind.
- Hard deadlines: identify in 45 days, close in 180 days and no later than your return due date. If the exchange crosses tax season, extend your return or the 180 days get cut short.
- Don't touch the money. A qualified intermediary (QI) holds the proceeds. If you can reach the funds, the exchange can fail. Your accountant, attorney or broker from the last 2 years can't serve as your QI.
- To defer everything: buy at or above the net sale price, reinvest all the net proceeds, and take on at least as much debt (or add cash). Cash and debt relief are boot, taxed up to the gain, with prior depreciation taxed at up to 25%.
- Foreign sellers: the buyer generally withholds 15% under FIRPTA. File Form 8288-B on or before closing to request reduced withholding based on nonrecognition; you need an ITIN, and you then file Form 1040-NR with Form 8824. California property exchanged out of state means filing FTB 3840 every year.
What is a 1031 exchange, and how much tax can it save?
Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code lets you exchange real property held for business or investment for other like-kind real property without paying tax on the gain now. The gain rolls into the new property and is taxed when you eventually sell without exchanging. It's a deferral, not an exemption. But if you keep exchanging until you die, your heirs generally get a basis equal to fair market value, and the deferred gain is never subject to federal income tax.
Selling a typical rental triggers three layers of tax: the depreciation you took (unrecaptured section 1250 gain) at up to 25%; the rest of the long-term gain at 0%, 15% or 20%; and for higher incomes, the 3.8% net investment income tax (NIIT). State tax comes on top. A 1031 exchange pushes all of it into the future.
Example (hypothetical numbers, to show the method): a North Carolina rental bought in 2016 for $500,000 has $130,000 of depreciation, for an adjusted basis of $370,000. It sells in 2026 for $800,000 with $40,000 of selling and exchange costs, for a $390,000 gain. Assuming the long-term gain falls in the 15% bracket: $130,000 × 25% = $32,500 plus $260,000 × 15% = $39,000, about $71,500 federal. If income is high enough for the full gain to be subject to NIIT, add about $14,820, and North Carolina's 3.99% adds about $15,561. That's roughly $100,000. In a 1031 exchange, all of that stays invested in the new property.
Description: Read top to bottom in time order. The third column shows who handles each step; YCL handles the tax side.
| Stage | What happens | Who handles it |
|---|---|---|
| Before listing | Confirm the property qualifies, compute the gain and how much to reinvest, set the timeline; foreign sellers prepare the ITIN and Form 8288-B | You and your CPA (YCL) |
| Before closing | Sign the exchange agreement with the QI, assign the sale contract to the QI, notify the buyer | QI, closing attorney or title company |
| Sale closes | Proceeds go straight to the QI, never to you; day 1 starts the next day | Closing attorney or title company, QI |
| By day 45 | Sign and deliver the written identification to the QI | You; your CPA checks the rules and amounts |
| By day 180 (and the return due date) | The QI uses the funds to buy the replacement property, titled to you (the same taxpayer) | QI, closing attorney or title company |
| Tax filing | Form 8824, Form 4797 or Schedule D, new depreciation schedules; Form 1040-NR for foreign sellers; FTB 3840 if California property was exchanged out | CPA (YCL) |
What property qualifies? What about my home, a vacation home or property in China?
Since 2018, Section 1031 applies only to real property, and both the property you give up and the property you get must be held for business or investment. Almost any U.S. real estate is like-kind to any other: raw land for an apartment building, a single-family rental for a retail building, a warehouse for an office. Your home, property held primarily for sale (development or fix-and-flip), and property outside the U.S. don't qualify.
| Property | 1031 eligible? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Long-term rentals (single-family, condo, multifamily) | Yes | The most common case |
| Retail, office, warehouse, industrial, land, farmland | Yes | Improved and unimproved real property are like-kind |
| Your principal residence | No | Look at the section 121 home sale exclusion instead (below) |
| Fix-and-flip or development property for sale | No | Held primarily for sale, like inventory |
| Vacation or second homes | Usually not, unless the safe harbor is met | See Rev. Proc. 2008-16 below |
| Furniture, equipment, vehicles | No | Personal property is out since 2018; personal property you receive is boot |
| Partnership or LLC interests | No | Excluded by section 1031(a)(2), unless the partnership has a valid election out of the partnership rules |
| Property in China or elsewhere abroad | Not with U.S. property | Section 1031(h): U.S. and foreign real property are not like-kind |
- The vacation home safe harbor (Rev. Proc. 2008-16): you owned the property for at least 24 months right before the exchange; in each of those two 12-month periods you rented it at fair rent for at least 14 days; and your personal use didn't exceed the greater of 14 days or 10% of the days rented. The replacement property has to meet the same tests for the 24 months after the exchange. Missing the safe harbor doesn't automatically disqualify you, but then it comes down to the facts.
- How long must I hold it? The law sets no minimum holding period. What matters is your intent and the actual use. Selling right after buying, or buying to resell, is risky. Rent the replacement long term and keep the leases, listings and Schedule E as evidence.
- Property in China: it can't be exchanged for U.S. property. Two properties both outside the U.S. can be like-kind in principle, but a Chinese transaction rarely fits the QI-held-funds structure, so it's almost never used in practice. For U.S. tax on selling a home in China, see yclcpa.com/chinahome.
How do the 45 and 180 days work, and what's the tax return due date trap?
Day 1 is the day after the relinquished property transfers. By midnight of day 45, you must identify the replacement property in a signed writing delivered to the QI. By midnight of day 180, or your return due date including extensions if that's earlier, you must receive it. Weekends and holidays don't extend these deadlines; only special relief, such as for federally declared disasters, does.
Description: The same exchange has different end dates depending on whether you extend your return; a foreign seller filing Form 1040-NR has a later due date.
| Milestone | Date (example) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Relinquished property transfers | 2026-11-02 | Proceeds go directly to the QI |
| Day 45 | 2026-12-17 | Identification deadline; no new properties after this |
| Return due date (U.S. resident, Form 1040) | 2027-04-15 | Without an extension, the exchange period ends here |
| Day 180 | 2027-05-01 | With a 2026 extension (Form 4868), the exchange period runs to this date |
| Form 1040-NR due date (nonresident without U.S. wages) | 2027-06-15 | Later than day 180, so day 180 controls |
Identification rules (Treas. Reg. §1.1031(k)-1(c)):
- In writing, signed, delivered on time to the QI or another party to the exchange, not just to your own attorney, accountant or agent. You can revoke and re-identify in writing within the 45 days.
- Unambiguous: a street address, legal description or distinguishable name, not "a unit in such-and-such complex."
- Three-property rule: up to 3 properties, regardless of value.
- 200% rule: more than 3 properties, as long as their total value doesn't exceed 200% of the property you sold.
- 95% rule: if you exceed both, you must actually acquire at least 95% of the total value identified, or it's treated as if nothing was identified.
- Property received within the 45 days counts as identified.
- Property under construction can be identified, but only what's completed when you receive it counts as like-kind (see improvement exchanges below).
The classic trap is the year-end sale. If you sell after mid-October, day 180 falls after April 15. Without an extension, the exchange period ends on April 15, and if you haven't closed on the replacement by then, the exchange fails. Extend your return or close before the due date.
What is a qualified intermediary, and why can't the money touch my account?
In a deferred exchange, you can't actually or constructively receive the sale proceeds. If the money lands in your hands or your account, or you can demand it at any time, you've received it: it becomes boot and the whole exchange may fail. So you sign an exchange agreement with a QI before the sale closes, and the QI receives the money and uses it to buy your replacement property.
- Constructive receipt counts. Money credited to you, set apart for you, or available for you to draw on is treated as received, and receipt by your agent is receipt by you.
- The agreement must restrict your access. The regulations require that you have no right to receive, pledge, borrow or otherwise obtain the benefits of the money before the exchange period ends. The exceptions are narrow: no property was identified by day 45; you've received everything you identified; or a material, written contingency beyond your control occurred.
- Who can't be your QI: anyone who served as your employee, attorney, accountant, investment banker or broker, or real estate agent or broker within the 2 years before the sale, plus people related to you or to them at more than 10%. That means a CPA who has prepared your returns, including us, can't be your QI. Services for the 1031 exchange itself, and routine title, escrow and bank services, don't count.
- QI risk: QIs aren't federally regulated financial institutions, and state oversight varies. Look at whether funds sit in segregated, insured accounts, whether there's a fidelity bond or insurance, and how the agreement restricts use of the funds.
Who sells has to buy: same taxpayer, LLCs, partnerships, TICs and DSTs
Generally the taxpayer who sells the old property must be the one who buys the new one. If you own it individually, buy individually (or through your single-member LLC). If a partnership owns it, the partnership buys the replacement; partners can't each take their share and exchange separately.
- Single-member LLCs are disregarded for tax purposes, so buying through yours is generally treated as buying it yourself.
- Spouses: if the old property is in one name and the new one in two (or the reverse), sort out title and filing status in advance.
- Partnerships and multi-member LLCs: when partners want to go separate ways, a common approach is to distribute the property to the partners as tenants in common and let each exchange, the so-called drop and swap. The IRS has no safe harbor for it; timing, intent to hold and documentation all matter, so it needs case-by-case review.
- Tenancy-in-common (TIC) interests in real property can be replacement property; Rev. Proc. 2002-22 lists the conditions the IRS considers for a ruling.
- Delaware statutory trust (DST) interests can be treated as direct interests in real property under Rev. Rul. 2004-86, which makes them popular with owners who don't want to manage property. They're investment products with their own risks, fees and liquidity limits. YCL doesn't sell investment products.
- The related-party 2-year rule (section 1031(f)): if you exchange directly with a sibling, spouse, parent, child or a company you control by more than 50%, and either side disposes of the property within 2 years, the deferred gain is generally taxed in the year of that disposition. Exceptions cover death, involuntary conversions (such as condemnation or casualty), and transactions without a tax avoidance purpose. Buying replacement property from a related party who cashes out generally doesn't work either (Rev. Rul. 2002-83). Related-party exchanges are reported on Form 8824 for the 2 years after the exchange as well.
What is boot, and how do I defer all of the gain?
Boot is anything you receive that isn't like-kind property: cash, debt relief, personal property, a note from the buyer. The exchange still works, but you're taxed on the smaller of the boot or your gain. To defer everything, remember three rules: buy at or above the net sale price; reinvest all the net proceeds; and take on at least as much debt, or make up the difference with your own cash.
- Cash boot: money the QI returns to you at the end, plus exchange funds used for non-exchange costs, such as prorated property taxes or HOA dues and fees on your new loan.
- Mortgage boot: if the debt paid off on the old property exceeds the debt on the new one, the difference is boot. Cash you add can offset mortgage boot, but extra borrowing can't offset cash you receive.
- Exchange expenses: commissions, title and closing costs, QI fees and exchange-related legal fees reduce boot and become part of the new basis.
- Partial exchanges are allowed. The cash you take out is taxed; the rest stays deferred.
- No losses: a loss in an exchange can't be deducted; it carries into the new property's basis.
Worked example: filling in Form 8824
Part III of Form 8824 works in this order: compute the realized gain (line 19), look at boot (line 15), recognize the smaller of the two (lines 20–23), and the rest is deferred (line 24). The new property's basis is on line 25.
Example (hypothetical numbers, to show the method): the same rental sells for $800,000, with a $200,000 mortgage, $40,000 of selling and exchange costs paid at closing, and an adjusted basis of $370,000. The QI receives $560,000 net. Here are two ways to buy.
Description: Column A buys a more expensive property with more debt. Column B buys a cheaper one, takes cash back and carries less debt.
| Form 8824 line | A: buy for $1,000,000, new loan $440,000 | B: buy for $700,000, new loan $180,000, $40,000 cash back |
|---|---|---|
| Line 15: cash plus net debt relief | $0 | $40,000 + $20,000 = $60,000 |
| Line 16: FMV of like-kind property received | $1,000,000 | $700,000 |
| Line 17: lines 15 + 16 | $1,000,000 | $760,000 |
| Line 18: adjusted basis given up plus amounts paid | $370,000 + net new debt $240,000 = $610,000 | $370,000 |
| Line 19: realized gain | $390,000 | $390,000 |
| Line 20: smaller of line 15 or 19 | $0 | $60,000 |
| Line 23: recognized (taxable) gain | $0 | $60,000 |
| Line 24: deferred gain | $390,000 | $330,000 |
| Line 25: basis of new property | $610,000 | $370,000 |
- Where did the $40,000 of expenses go? It was paid at closing out of the sale proceeds, so it offsets the cash deemed received for it and doesn't appear separately on line 15 in either column. Expenses you pay out of pocket go on line 18.
- Check: new basis = price of the new property − deferred gain. A: $1,000,000 − $390,000 = $610,000. B: $700,000 − $330,000 = $370,000.
- How B's $60,000 is taxed: line 21 is ordinary-income recapture, which is generally zero for residential rentals depreciated straight-line. The $60,000 is less than the $130,000 of prior depreciation, so it's generally all unrecaptured section 1250 gain, taxed at up to 25% and carried through Form 4797 to Schedule D.
- What full deferral would take in B: the price is $60,000 below the $760,000 net sale price, and that gap shows up as boot whether it comes out as cash or as a smaller loan. To defer everything, buy for at least $760,000, reinvest all $560,000 and borrow at least $200,000 (or add your own cash).
How do I depreciate the new property, and where does the old depreciation go?
The depreciation you took doesn't disappear. It travels with the deferred gain to the new property and is taxed when you finally sell without exchanging. The new property's basis is depreciated in two pieces: the carried-over basis continues on the old property's remaining schedule and method, and any excess basis (from new debt or added cash) starts fresh as a newly acquired asset.
- Treas. Reg. §1.168(i)-6 governs this. You may instead elect to treat the entire basis as newly placed in service; the election isn't something to flip later.
- 27.5 years for residential rentals, 39 years for commercial: land isn't depreciable, so allocate the basis between land and building first (property tax assessments are a common reference).
- Different property types, such as residential into commercial, need the remaining recovery period and method worked out item by item.
- Take depreciation on time. Depreciation you could have taken is treated as taken and recaptured on sale either way (see yclcpa.com/rental).
- Cost segregation and bonus depreciation on the new property bring future recapture and state differences into play, so model them first.
Buy first or build: reverse and improvement exchanges
If you need to buy before you sell, use a reverse exchange: an exchange accommodation titleholder (EAT) holds title to the new or old property under the Rev. Proc. 2000-37 safe harbor, and everything wraps up within 180 days. If you want exchange funds to build on or improve the replacement property, use an improvement exchange, but only the work completed by the time you take title counts as like-kind property.
- Reverse exchange deadlines (Rev. Proc. 2000-37): a written agreement within 5 business days after the EAT takes title; identify the relinquished property within 45 days; complete within 180 days; and the combined time both properties sit with the EAT can't exceed 180 days.
- You can't park property you already own. Rev. Proc. 2004-51 takes property you owned within the 180 days before the transfer to the EAT out of the safe harbor. Handing your own lot to an EAT to build on and then exchanging into it isn't covered.
- Improvement exchanges: the EAT holds the land or building while exchange funds pay for construction within the 180 days. Only improvements in place when you receive the property count; later work doesn't, and unspent funds are boot.
- Cost and timing: reverse and improvement exchanges require separate financing (you have to fund the purchase first), more documents and higher fees. Build the schedule early with the QI or EAT, your lender and the closing attorney or title company.
Converting a rental to a home, or a home to a rental: how do Sections 1031 and 121 fit together?
If you move into a property you received in a 1031 exchange and later sell it, you must own it for 5 years from the exchange before the section 121 home sale exclusion ($250,000, or $500,000 joint) is available. The rental years count as nonqualified use, so part of the gain isn't excludable, and the depreciation is taxed. Going the other way, a home converted to a rental and then exchanged can use both section 121 and section 1031.
- The 5-year rule (section 121(d)(10)): no exclusion for a sale within 5 years of acquiring the property in a 1031 exchange, even if you lived there 2 years.
- Nonqualified use (section 121(b)(5)): periods after 2008 when the property wasn't your main home (other than time after you last lived there) reduce the exclusion in proportion to your total ownership.
- Depreciation is recaptured. Depreciation after May 6, 1997 can't be excluded and is taxed at up to 25%.
- Example (hypothetical numbers, to show the method): you acquire a property in a 1031 exchange in January 2027, rent it for 2 years, live in it for 3, and sell it in February 2032 (after the 5 years) for $900,000, filing jointly. Basis is $500,000, minus $30,000 of rental depreciation, for $470,000 and a $430,000 gain. The $30,000 is taxed first. Of the remaining $400,000, the 2 rental years are about 40% of the roughly 5-year ownership, so about $160,000 can't be excluded, and the remaining $240,000 or so is within the $500,000 limit.
- Home to rental, then exchange (Rev. Proc. 2005-14): if you lived in a home for years and then rented it, and you still meet the 2-of-5-year test when you exchange, you can exclude part of the gain under section 121 and defer the rest under section 1031; the excluded portion can absorb some cash boot. Plan how long to rent and when to exchange.
Exchanging until death: "swap till you drop," basis step-up and estate tax
If the deferred gain is never cashed out, your heirs generally take a basis equal to fair market value at your death (section 1014), and the deferred gain and depreciation recapture escape federal income tax. That's "swap till you drop." Estate tax is a separate question, and for people who aren't U.S. citizens or residents, U.S. real estate above $60,000 is exposed.
- U.S. citizens and residents: starting in 2026, the federal estate and gift tax exemption is $15,000,000 (made permanent by the OBBBA and indexed for inflation), so most families owe no federal estate tax.
- Non-citizen nonresidents: U.S. real estate is U.S.-situs property. Value above $60,000 faces estate tax at 18% to 40% on Form 706-NA, and heirs often need an IRS transfer certificate before title or accounts can move (see yclcpa.com/estate).
- Lifetime gifts get no step-up. A child who receives the property as a gift generally takes your basis, deferred gain and all.
- Giving up a green card: a covered expatriate is treated as selling everything at fair market value, which can trigger the deferred gain (see yclcpa.com/exittax).
- States: some, such as California, keep tracking gain on out-of-state replacement property; state rules on inherited property vary.
Nonresidents and people who moved abroad: FIRPTA 15%, Form 8288-B, ITIN and Form 1040-NR
When a foreign seller (an individual without a green card who doesn't meet the substantial presence test, or a foreign corporation) sells U.S. real estate, the buyer generally withholds 15% of the price. In a 1031 exchange, you can file Form 8288-B on or before closing to request reduced or no withholding on the ground that nonrecognition applies. The application needs an ITIN, which you can request with Form W-7 at the same time. You then file Form 1040-NR with Form 8824.
- Withholding isn't waived automatically. The buyer (in practice the closing attorney or title company) can't skip withholding just because you say it's a 1031. If the 8288-B was submitted by closing, the withheld amount can be held and paid over by the 20th day after the IRS mails its certificate or denial.
- What to attach (line 7a): a brief description of the transfer, a summary of the law, facts supporting nonrecognition, evidence that you have no unsatisfied withholding liability, and the latest assessed value. For a 1031, we generally include the exchange agreement, the QI's details and how the exchange is structured. The IRS normally acts within 90 days of receiving everything it needs.
- With boot, the application is based on the maximum tax on the boot, so only that portion is withheld.
- Withholding can break the exchange. Money withheld never reaches the QI, so you're short when buying the replacement. To defer everything you generally need to make it up from other funds, or the shortfall can become boot. Any overwithholding comes back only when you file Form 1040-NR.
- Foreign persons' exchanges: under Treas. Reg. §1.897-6T, a foreign person gets nonrecognition only if the property received is also a U.S. real property interest (taxable on a later sale). That matches the U.S.-for-U.S. requirement of Section 1031.
- Form 1040-NR and Form 8824: file Form 1040-NR for the exchange year with Form 8824 and depreciation schedules. Missing returns for earlier rental years need to be filed too, with depreciation computed as allowable (see yclcpa.com/1040nr and yclcpa.com/firpta). A nonresident without U.S. wages has until June 15 of the following year.
- Green card holders and citizens who moved back to China are still U.S. tax residents taxed on worldwide income on Form 1040. Their U.S. property can be exchanged, but not for property in China. If you plan to give up a green card, run the exit tax numbers first.
- State withholding: some states withhold separately on nonresident sellers (next section). North Carolina doesn't; the buyer files Form NC-1099NRS.
What about state tax? California FTB 3840, Oregon OR-24 and state withholding
Most states with an income tax follow the federal 1031 deferral, but the state where the property sits usually keeps the right to tax the gain later. If you exchange California property for property in another state, you file FTB 3840 every year until the deferred gain is recognized, and Oregon has a similar annual OR-24. Many states also require buyers to withhold on nonresident sellers, usually with a way to claim a 1031 exemption or reduction.
| State | Rule | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| California | For taxable years beginning in 2014 or later, California property exchanged for out-of-state property means an annual FTB 3840; when the out-of-state property is sold, the California-source deferred gain is taxed by California even if you no longer live there | File in the exchange year and every year after; if you don't, the FTB can estimate income and assess tax. Buyers withhold 3⅓% of the price; Form 593 has a 1031 exchange box |
| Oregon | Oregon property exchanged out of state means filing OR-24 for the exchange year and every year until the replacement is disposed of | The Oregon-source deferred gain is reported to Oregon on disposition |
| Massachusetts, Montana | Often listed as having similar clawback rules | Confirm the current state rules before exchanging property out of these states |
| North Carolina | No state withholding; buyers file Form NC-1099NRS for nonresident sellers | Gain on North Carolina property is reported to North Carolina; we haven't seen an annual tracking form like California's 3840 |
| Other withholding states | New York, Maryland, Maine, Oregon, Alabama, Massachusetts and others require withholding or estimated payments from nonresident sellers, with different rates and exemptions | Check before closing and claim the exemption or reduction on the state form |
- Moving to a no-tax state doesn't erase the gain. Exchange California property into Texas property, and the California share of the deferred gain shows up on a California nonresident return when you sell in Texas.
- Conformity varies: states adopted federal 1031 changes on different timelines, and a few have had their own differences. Follow the state revenue department's rules.
How is it reported? Form 8824, Form 4797 and the records to keep
Attach Form 8824 to the return for the year of the exchange. If it spans two years, report it in the year the relinquished property transferred, and extend if the replacement hasn't closed when you file. Recognized gain on business property flows through Form 4797 to Schedule D, and ordinary recapture goes in Part III of Form 4797. Depreciation on the new property starts on Form 4562 and Schedule E from the closing date.
- Which year: the year the relinquished property transferred. Sell in November 2026, buy in March 2027, and it goes on the 2026 return.
- Form 4797 or Schedule D: rentals are generally section 1231 business property, so recognized gain goes through Form 4797 to Schedule D; land held purely for investment goes straight to Schedule D.
- Related-party exchanges: Part II of Form 8824 for the exchange year and the next 2 years.
- Several properties: one summary Form 8824 with a statement for each exchange; multi-asset exchanges with several groups or cash get your own attached computation.
- State forms: FTB 3840 for California, OR-24 for Oregon, and other states' forms as required.
- Records to keep: closing statements and improvement invoices for the old property and its depreciation history; the exchange agreement, assignment notices and 45-day identification; both closing statements (Closing Disclosure or settlement statement); the QI's account statement; old and new loan documents; and for foreign sellers, the 8288-B, the IRS response and Form 8288-A. Keep them until the statute of limitations runs on the return for the year you finally sell the replacement.
When we prepare a 1031 return, we start by breaking down both closing statements line by line: exchange expenses, boot, and amounts that belong in basis. Then come Form 8824, the depreciation schedules and the state forms. Timing-wise, a month or two before you list is best, since a foreign seller's 8288-B and ITIN have to be ready by closing.
Did the 2025–2026 tax law change Section 1031? What changed for opportunity zones?
As of November 2026, the 1031 rules are unchanged. The One, Big, Beautiful Bill (OBBBA), signed July 4, 2025, didn't limit like-kind exchanges, and an earlier Biden administration budget proposal to cap deferral at $500,000 was never enacted. What the OBBBA did change is opportunity zones: deferred gain in existing opportunity fund investments must be recognized on December 31, 2026, and permanent new rules apply from 2027.
Description: Rules in effect at the top, proposals that didn't pass at the bottom.
| Policy | Status | What it does | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|---|
| Real property only | In effect (exchanges from January 1, 2018) | Personal and intangible property no longer qualify | Furniture or equipment received with a building is boot |
| OBBBA and Section 1031 | No change (signed July 4, 2025) | 45 days, 180 days and full deferral unchanged | Follow current rules |
| Estate and gift tax exemption | In effect (from January 1, 2026) | $15,000,000 for U.S. citizens and residents, permanent, indexed | "Swap till you drop" works for most U.S. families; still $60,000 for nonresidents |
| New opportunity zone rules | In effect for investments from January 1, 2027 | Deferred gain recognized after 5 years, 10% basis increase at 5 years (30% for rural funds), post-10-year appreciation excludable; new zones effective January 1, 2027 | Only the gain needs to be invested and no real estate purchase is required; an alternative to 1031 |
| Existing opportunity zone investments | Deferral ends December 31, 2026 | Deferred gain on pre-2027 investments is recognized on December 31, 2026 | A 2026 investment under the old rules defers very little |
| $500,000 cap on 1031 deferral | Not enacted (earlier budget proposal) | No legislation | No cap under current law |
What are the most common 1031 mistakes?
Most failed exchanges don't fail on tax theory. They fail on timing and money flow: the money touched your account, the identification was vague, nobody extended the return, or the names on title didn't match.
| Mistake | Result | How to avoid it |
|---|---|---|
| Finding a QI after the sale closed | The money already reached you; no exchange | Sign the exchange agreement after the contract and before closing |
| Running the proceeds through your own account "just briefly" | Actual receipt; fully taxable | Funds move only between the QI and the closing parties |
| Rushing the identification on day 45 with vague descriptions | Invalid identification or no property to buy | Start shopping before you list and identify 2–3 backups |
| Selling after October without extending the return | The exchange period ends April 15 | Extend, or close before the due date |
| Selling from a company and buying in your own name | Not the same taxpayer | Keep the seller and buyer the same |
| Smaller loan on the new property with no added cash | Taxable mortgage boot | Match the old debt or add cash |
| Forgetting leftover funds the QI returned | Unreported boot | Get the QI's statement before filing |
| Moving into the replacement soon after | Looks like it wasn't held for investment; no section 121 for 5 years | Rent it long term and keep the evidence |
| Foreign seller without an ITIN or 8288-B in time | 15% withheld, possible boot | Start when you list |
| California property exchanged out, no FTB 3840 | California can estimate income and assess | File every year until the gain is recognized |
Key rules at a glance
| Item | Who / which form | Number / rule | Notes | Applies to |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eligible property | IRC §1031 | Real property only | Held for business or investment; not homes or property held primarily for sale | Exchanges from 2018 |
| U.S. vs. foreign property | IRC §1031(h) | Not like-kind | U.S. property can't be exchanged for property in China or elsewhere abroad | Current |
| Identification period | Treas. Reg. §1.1031(k)-1(b) | 45 days | Signed writing delivered to the QI or other party by midnight of day 45 | Current |
| Exchange period | Treas. Reg. §1.1031(k)-1(b) | 180 days or return due date | Whichever is earlier; extend if it crosses tax season | Current |
| Identification rules | Treas. Reg. §1.1031(k)-1(c) | 3 / 200% / 95% | Meet any one of them | Current |
| Disqualified person | Treas. Reg. §1.1031(k)-1(k) | 2 years | Your accountant, attorney, broker or employee in the last 2 years can't be your QI | Current |
| Related-party exchange | IRC §1031(f) · Form 8824 Part II | 2 years | Disposition by either side within 2 years generally triggers the gain; report for 2 more years | Current |
| Vacation home safe harbor | Rev. Proc. 2008-16 | 24 months · 14 days · 10% | 24 months before and after; rented 14+ days a year; personal use within 14 days or 10% | From March 10, 2008 |
| Reverse exchange safe harbor | Rev. Proc. 2000-37, 2004-51 | 5 business days · 45 days · 180 days | Not for property you owned within the prior 180 days | Current |
| Depreciation recapture | Unrecaptured §1250 gain | Up to 25% | Recognized boot is generally taxed here first; deferred recapture carries over | 2026 |
| Home sale exclusion and 1031 | IRC §121(d)(10) | 5 years | No exclusion within 5 years of a 1031 acquisition; rental years reduce it proportionally | Current |
| FIRPTA withholding | Foreign sellers · Forms 8288 / 8288-B | 15% | File 8288-B (line 7a, nonrecognition) by closing; IRS normally acts within 90 days | 2026 (8288-B Rev. 12-2025) |
| Reporting | Forms 8824 · 4797 · Schedule D | Year of the sale | Extend if the replacement hasn't closed; nonresidents attach to Form 1040-NR | 2026 |
| California tracking | FTB 3840 | Every year | California property exchanged out of state, until the gain is recognized; 3⅓% buyer withholding (Form 593 has a 1031 box) | From 2014 |
| Oregon tracking | Form OR-24 | Every year | Oregon property exchanged out of state, until the replacement is disposed of | Current |
| Opportunity zones | IRC §1400Z-2 (as amended by the OBBBA) | 5 years · 10% / 30% | New rules for investments from 2027; existing deferrals recognized December 31, 2026 | 2026–2027 |
Common mistakes
"A 1031 exchange means no tax."
It means later tax. The gain and the old depreciation move into the new property and are taxed when you sell without exchanging, recapture at up to 25% included. Only holding until death, with the basis step-up for your heirs, takes it off the federal income tax table.
"I just need to reinvest the profit."
Full deferral depends on price, proceeds and debt: buy at or above the net sale price, reinvest all the net proceeds and carry at least as much debt. Reinvest only the profit and take your original investment out, and what you take out is taxable boot.
"I'll sell first and figure it out within 45 days."
The QI has to be in place before the sale closes; once the money reaches you, it's too late. The 45 and 180 days don't stretch, and a sale late in the year needs a return extension.
"As a foreign seller doing a 1031, I won't have 15% withheld."
The buyer still withholds unless Form 8288-B was submitted on or before closing. Withheld money never reaches the QI and can become boot, so get the ITIN and 8288-B ready early.
A 1031 exchange, paying the tax, an installment sale or an opportunity zone: which fits?
Start with whether you want to keep owning U.S. real estate. If you do and can find the right property within 45 days, a 1031 exchange is the most direct path. If you want out and want cash, compare paying the tax now, an installment sale and an opportunity fund.
- Situation A: you want to keep investing in U.S. real estate and trade up or simplify. Do a 1031. Before selling, work out how much to reinvest and what loan you need, line up the QI when you list, and start looking at properties.
- Situation B: you want to stop being a landlord but keep the income. A 1031 into DST interests or triple-net (NNN) commercial property reduces the management burden. That's an investment decision with its own risks and fees; YCL handles only the tax side.
- Situation C: you want the cash and are done with real estate. Pay the tax, or use an installment sale (section 453) to spread the gain over the years you're paid. Installment obligations above $5,000,000 can carry an interest charge, and buyer default is a real risk. A partial 1031 with some cash out is also an option.
- Situation D: you only want to invest the gain, not buy property. Look at opportunity funds: for investments from 2027, the deferred gain is recognized after 5 years with a 10% basis increase (30% for rural funds), and appreciation after 10 years can be excluded. Investing in the existing program during 2026 defers almost nothing, since that gain is recognized at the end of 2026.
- Situation E: you're a foreign seller, or you've moved abroad and don't plan to keep U.S. property. Compute the FIRPTA withholding and your actual Form 1040-NR tax before selling. If you want to stay invested in the U.S., do a 1031 with an 8288-B, and factor in U.S. estate tax exposure (only $60,000 exempt).
- Situation F: you plan to move into the replacement someday. Check the 5-year rule and the nonqualified-use ratio, and compare exchanging now and excluding later with simply selling now.
The tax side of your 1031, from pre-sale planning to Form 8824
In a 1031 exchange, the QI holds the money and an attorney or title company handles the closing. We handle the tax side: before you sell, whether the exchange works, how much to reinvest and how much debt to carry, with the 45 days, 180 days and any return extension built into the schedule. Afterward, we work out boot, deferred gain and new basis from both closing statements and file Form 8824, Form 4797, depreciation schedules and state forms. For foreign sellers, we handle the ITIN, Form 8288-B and Form 1040-NR as well.
- Big Four background, 15+ years in U.S. tax, 10 years of U.S.–China cross-border work, credentialed as CPA, EA and CAA
- Numbers before you sell: gain, recapture, boot and the reinvestment target, with a side-by-side against paying the tax or an installment sale
- Foreign sellers: ITINs through our IRS Certifying Acceptance Agent status, Form 8288-B filed by closing, and Form 1040-NR the next year to recover overwithholding
- Filing: Form 8824, Form 4797, new depreciation schedules, California FTB 3840 and other state forms; the same team handles the rental years, the next exchange or the final sale
How it works
- 1
Free assessment
A free 15-minute call to see whether your property and status fit a 1031 and roughly how much you can defer.
- 2
Pre-sale planning
We compute the gain, the reinvestment target and the loan, and schedule the 45 days, 180 days and any extension; foreign sellers get the ITIN and 8288-B ready.
- 3
During the exchange
You work with the QI and the closing attorney or title company; we review the identification, closing statements and money flow for tax issues.
- 4
Filing and beyond
We file Form 8824, depreciation schedules and state forms (Form 1040-NR for nonresidents), then keep up the yearly rental returns and any state tracking filings.
FAQ
How are the 45 and 180 days counted in a 1031 exchange?
Day 1 is the day after the relinquished property transfers. By midnight of day 45 you must identify the replacement in a signed writing delivered to the QI, and by midnight of day 180, or your return due date with extensions if earlier, you must receive it. Weekends and holidays don't extend either deadline, so an exchange crossing tax season needs a return extension.
How much do I need to spend on the replacement to defer all the gain?
Buy at or above the net sale price (the price minus exchange expenses), reinvest all the net proceeds, and carry at least as much debt as you paid off, or add your own cash to make up the difference. Cash you receive and debt relief are boot, taxed up to the smaller of the boot or the gain.
Can I do a 1031 exchange with my home, a vacation home or property in China?
Not your principal residence, though section 121 may exclude the gain. A vacation home usually doesn't qualify unless it meets the 24-month rental safe harbor in Rev. Proc. 2008-16. U.S. and foreign real estate are not like-kind, and property held primarily for sale, such as flips, doesn't qualify either.
Will a foreign seller still have 15% withheld in a 1031 exchange?
Generally yes, unless Form 8288-B is submitted on or before closing to request reduced or no withholding because nonrecognition applies. You need an ITIN, and the IRS normally acts within 90 days of a complete application. Withheld money doesn't reach the QI and can become boot, and overwithholding is recovered on Form 1040-NR.
Can YCL help with the tax side of my 1031 exchange?
Yes. YCL CPA (yclcpa.com) handles the tax side: gain, boot and reinvestment numbers before you sell, the timeline, and the ITIN and Form 8288-B for foreign sellers; afterward, Form 8824, Form 4797, depreciation schedules, state forms and Form 1040-NR. The QI holds the funds and an attorney or title company handles the closing, and results depend on your facts and on the IRS and state agencies. Book a free 15-minute call to start.
Related guides
- Real EstateHow do I report a rental property on Schedule E, and what can I deduct?
- Cross-BorderHow much FIRPTA withholding applies when a nonresident sells a U.S. home?
- Individuals & FamiliesHow are investments taxed? Stocks, funds, interest, real estate and foreign investments, plus 20 legal ways to pay less
Sources
- Internal Revenue Code §1031 (including (a)(2), (f) and (h)), §121 (including (b)(5) and (d)(10)), §1014, §1250, §453, §1445, §1400Z-2 (as amended by Pub. L. 119-21, July 4, 2025)
- Treas. Reg. §1.1031(k)-1 (deferred exchanges, identification, safe harbors, disqualified persons); §1.1031(a)-3 (definition of real property, T.D. 9935, 2020); §1.168(i)-6 (depreciation after an exchange); §1.897-6T (nonrecognition for foreign persons)
- IRS: Instructions for Form 8824 (IRS page updated November 12, 2026); Form 8824
- IRS: Like-Kind Exchanges – Real Estate Tax Tips; FS-2008-18 (marked historical by the IRS); Publication 544
- IRS: Rev. Proc. 2000-37 and Rev. Proc. 2004-51 (reverse exchanges); Rev. Proc. 2008-16 (vacation home safe harbor); Rev. Proc. 2005-14 (sections 121 and 1031 together); Rev. Proc. 2002-22 (TIC); Rev. Rul. 2004-86 (DST); Rev. Rul. 2002-83 (related parties)
- IRS: Form 8288-B (Rev. 12-2025) and instructions; Instructions for Forms 8288 and 8288-A; Publications 515 and 519
- IRS / Treasury: IR-2026-45 (April 2026, new opportunity zone designations); Notice 2025-50 (rural opportunity funds)
- California FTB: Form 3840 and instructions (2025); Form 593 and Publication 1016 (revised February 2026)
- Oregon Department of Revenue: Form OR-24 instructions; North Carolina Department of Revenue: Form NC-1099NRS
Selling a rental and thinking about a 1031?
Book a free 15-minute call. A CPA will estimate how much you can defer, how much to reinvest and how to time it, and check FIRPTA withholding if you're a foreign seller, with no fee and no sales pitch.
