Insights / Immigration & residency tax

Proving Ability to Pay for an I-140: The Tax Returns, Annual Reports and Financial Statements an Employer Needs

Under 8 CFR 204.5(g)(2), an I-140 uses annual reports, federal tax returns or audited financial statements to show the employer could pay the PERM wage from the priority date on. USCIS generally checks wages paid, net income and net current assets. Plus the usual small-company problems: losses, wages that don't tie, no Schedule L and mixed money.

Published By YCL CPA
Questions? Reach us directly

Message us on WhatsApp

Scan the code with WhatsApp, or tap the button if you are on your phone.

919-802-8376Open WhatsApp

Add us on WeChat

Scan the code with WeChat, or copy the WeChat ID and search for it in the app.

WeChat ID: YCLUSA
FacebookInstagramXRednoteWeChat Channels
Proving Ability to Pay for an I-140: The Tax Returns, Annual Reports and Financial Statements an Employer Needs

An I-140 has to show the employer could pay the wage on the PERM from the priority date (usually the PERM filing date) until the worker gets the green card. Under 8 CFR 204.5(g)(2), the evidence is annual reports, federal tax returns or audited financial statements; employers with 100 or more U.S. workers can use a statement from a financial officer. USCIS generally looks first at what the company actually paid this worker, then net income on the return, then net current assets. For small and new companies, the problems usually come from the books and the returns.

What the regulation says

The basic rule: the employer shows it could pay the PERM wage as of the priority date and continuing until the worker becomes a permanent resident. The evidence is copies of annual reports, federal tax returns or audited financial statements.

Large employers: with 100 or more U.S. employees, USCIS may accept a statement from a financial officer.

Supporting evidence: profit-and-loss statements, bank statements and payroll records can supplement the case, but generally don't replace those three. Unaudited financial statements aren't "audited financial statements."

Three things USCIS usually checks

First, wages actually paid. If the worker already works there, USCIS looks at the W-2 or 1099. For each year from the priority date on, wages at or above the PERM wage generally settle that year. If they fall short, the question is whether the next two tests cover the gap.

Second, net income on the return. Whether the company's net income for the year, or the shortfall, covers the PERM wage. For a C corporation that's taxable income on Form 1120; for S corporations and partnerships, items such as ordinary business income on Schedule K.

Third, net current assets. Year-end current assets minus current liabilities, usually from the Schedule L balance sheet on the return or from the financial statements. Enough net current assets to cover the wage, or the gap, also works.

Several sponsored workers: an employer sponsoring several people has to show it can pay all of them on pending and approved petitions, not just this one.

The bigger picture: if all three fall short, USCIS may consider the company's history, size, headcount and unusual one-time expenses, but that's an exception to plan around, not on.

Which years' returns count

Every year from the priority date on. If PERM was filed in 2026, 2026 is the first year. The company's 2026 return isn't filed until 2027, so it may not exist when the I-140 goes in, and a request for evidence often asks for it once it's filed.

During the I-140 and the wait for a visa number, each year's return can come up, especially with a downgrade or upgrade that means a new I-140, or an I-485 transferred to another category.

An example

Example (hypothetical numbers, to show the math): a 12-person software company in North Carolina files PERM for employee J in April 2026 at a PERM wage of $110,000 a year. J is on H-1B and earns $100,000 on the 2026 W-2, a $10,000 shortfall.

Wages paid: $100,000 is short of $110,000 by $10,000 for 2026.

Net income: the company's 2026 taxable income is $6,000, not enough to cover the $10,000 gap.

Net current assets: at the end of 2026, Schedule L shows $85,000 of current assets and $60,000 of current liabilities, so net current assets are $25,000, more than the $10,000 gap. 2026 is generally covered.

If the company is also sponsoring another worker, add both shortfalls together before comparing. Raising J's pay to at least the PERM wage from 2027 lets each later year be proven straight from the W-2.

Where small companies run into trouble

A loss on the return: profit squeezed down to save tax, or a loss, while the worker isn't paid the full PERM wage, makes ability to pay hard to prove.

Wages that don't tie: wage expense on the return, the 941s, the W-2 and the PERM wage don't match each other.

No Schedule L: Forms 1120 and 1120-S can skip Schedule L when total receipts and total assets are both under $250,000, but then net current assets aren't visible, so prepare a separate balance sheet.

Mixed money: the owner pays company costs on a personal card or personal costs from the company account, and the financial statements can't explain themselves.

New companies: with little history and no full returns yet, the evidence is thin, so plan ahead.

How we prepare it

Pay the full PERM wage through payroll from the priority-date year on. Paying the worker at least the PERM wage on the W-2 is the most direct proof. If the worker is already on H-1B and the LCA wage differs from the PERM wage, plan for the difference early.

Monthly books, annual tie-out. Reconcile bank and card accounts every month, record income and expenses on time, and produce a balance sheet and income statement at year-end.

Returns that match the statements. Revenue, wage expense and Schedule L on the return should agree with the financial statements, W-2s and 941s.

If audited statements are needed, plan early. An audit has to come from an independent CPA firm, and a firm that keeps your books or makes management decisions generally can't also audit you. We do bookkeeping, financial statements and returns, and if an audit is needed we'll lay out the practical options.

If you're sponsoring yourself through your own company, keep company and personal money strictly separate, and make sure payroll, returns and statements hold up to review; see your own company and H-1B.

For the full picture

PERM and I-140 steps, timing and fees, plus China-born EB-2 and EB-3 dates and downgrades, are in our guide, Planning your H-1B and green card for 2027; the types of financial statements are explained in our financial statements guide. Your immigration attorney handles the I-140, and we handle the tax and company side: payroll, bookkeeping, financial statements and corporate returns. Book a free 15-minute call, or message us on WeChat at YCLUSA.

Questions this article answers

What documents prove ability to pay for an I-140?

Under 8 CFR 204.5(g)(2): annual reports, federal tax returns or audited financial statements. Employers with 100 or more U.S. workers can use a financial officer's statement. P&Ls, bank statements and payroll records can supplement.

Can a company with a loss on its return still prove ability to pay?

Possibly. If it paid this worker the full PERM wage that year, that generally works; if not, net current assets may cover the gap. Only when all of these fall short might USCIS look at the overall picture, which isn't something to count on.

Which year does it start?

The priority-date year, usually when PERM was filed, and every year until the green card. If that year's return wasn't filed when the I-140 went in, USCIS often asks for it in a request for evidence.

Can the accountant who keeps our books also audit our statements?

Usually not. An audit has to come from an independent CPA firm, and a firm that keeps your books or makes management decisions generally isn't independent. Your bookkeeper can prepare the statements and returns, with the audit arranged separately.

Ready to talk? The first 15 minutes are on us.

Book online, or send us a few details and we will come back with a written quote within one business day.

Book a callQuick quote