PLLC or S Corp? For Professionals It Isn’t Either/Or: Pick the Entity, Then the Tax Election
A PLLC is a state-law professional entity and an S corp is a federal tax election, so you can have both. Many North Carolina doctors, dentists and CPAs form a PLLC, then file Form 2553 once profits are steady and take a reasonable salary. Fix the operating agreement so distributions follow ownership first.

A PLLC and an S corp aren't alternatives. A PLLC is a state-law entity that decides whether you can practice through the company and who can own it. An S corp is a federal tax election that decides how the profit is taxed. Plenty of North Carolina doctors, dentists and CPAs form a PLLC first and then file Form 2553 to elect S status once profits are steady.
Two questions, answered separately
Professionals often ask us, "Should I form a PLLC or an S corp?" Those are really two different questions.
The first is a state-law question: which entity can you practice through? In North Carolina, physicians, dentists, CPAs, attorneys, engineers, counselors and other professions listed in the Professional Corporation Act (Chapter 55B) can't practice through a regular LLC. They need a PLLC or a professional corporation (PC / PA). The owners generally must be licensed in the profession, and the licensing board certifies the entity before it's formed.
The second is a tax question: how is that entity taxed? Federal tax law doesn't know the word "PLLC." A single-member PLLC is a disregarded entity by default, so the profit goes on your Schedule C. A multi-member PLLC is a partnership by default and files Form 1065. Either one can file Form 2553 to be taxed as an S corporation, and the IRS treats it as also electing corporate classification, so no separate Form 8832 is needed.
That gives you several combinations: a PLLC taxed as a sole proprietorship, a PLLC taxed as a partnership, a PLLC taxed as an S corp, a professional corporation taxed as a C corp, or a professional corporation taxed as an S corp. Settle the entity first, then the tax treatment.
What does an S election actually save?
It saves Social Security and Medicare tax. A sole proprietor's or single-member PLLC's profit is all subject to self-employment tax: 12.4% Social Security (on earnings up to $184,500 in 2026) and 2.9% Medicare (no cap). With an S election, you work for the company and take a reasonable salary through payroll. The salary still bears both taxes, split between you and the company, but profit left after the salary comes out as distributions without Social Security or Medicare tax.
Example (hypothetical numbers, to show the method): a single-member dental PLLC earns $300,000 in 2026 before paying the owner, who is single. Without an S election, the tax base is $300,000 × 92.35% = $277,050. Social Security is $184,500 × 12.4% = $22,878 and Medicare is $277,050 × 2.9% = $8,034, about $30,912 in total. With an S election and a $150,000 reasonable salary, Social Security is $18,600 and Medicare $4,350, for $22,950, about $7,962 less. That ignores the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax, income tax and state tax, and it doesn't subtract the yearly cost of payroll service, the Form 1120-S and North Carolina franchise tax.
Why do professionals need a higher reasonable salary?
A professional practice earns its money mainly from your license and your own work. The IRS has no formula. It asks what your work is worth in the market: your license and experience, the hours you put in, what employed doctors or CPAs in your area earn, and how much revenue comes from you versus staff and equipment. In a practice where one doctor sees the patients or one CPA does the work, the salary is usually a bigger share of profit than in a trading or e-commerce company.
The most common problem is a token salary with everything else paid as distributions, or no salary at all. In S corp cases involving CPAs, physicians and other professionals, the IRS and the courts have repeatedly recharacterized distributions as wages, with back payroll tax, penalties and interest. Write down how you set the salary and keep it on file.
Fix the PLLC's operating agreement before you elect
An S corp can have only one class of stock, and profit must be distributed in proportion to ownership. A multi-member PLLC's operating agreement, written for a partnership, often includes special allocations, such as splitting profit by each doctor's collections or giving a preferred return to the member who put in more capital. That works in a partnership. In an S corp it can look like a second class of stock and put the election at risk. Change the distribution terms to pro rata before electing, and reflect differences in production through salary and bonuses instead.
Every member must also be a U.S. citizen or resident, with no more than 100 shareholders. If a member moves abroad and becomes a nonresident, S status ends that day.
When do you file Form 2553?
File it within 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year you want it to take effect, or any time in the prior year. For a calendar-year company starting January 1, 2027, the deadline is March 15, 2027. For a newly formed PLLC, the clock starts on the first day it has members, acquires assets or begins business. If you miss it and have reasonable cause, Rev. Proc. 2013-30 allows relief within 3 years and 75 days of the intended effective date.
Once you elect, you run payroll, file Form 941 plus North Carolina withholding and unemployment returns, issue W-2s, and file Form 1120-S with K-1s every year.
What's different in North Carolina?
North Carolina follows the federal S election with no separate state filing. A PLLC that elects S status files Form CD-401S and pays franchise tax (minimum $200); a PLLC taxed as a partnership or sole proprietorship doesn't pay franchise tax. Higher-earning owners should also look at North Carolina's PTE election. An S corp or multi-member PLLC can elect each year on a timely filed state return to pay North Carolina income tax for its owners at 3.99% (2026), which works around the federal SALT cap ($40,400 for 2026, phasing back to $10,000 once income passes $505,000).
The S election also affects QBI and retirement plans
Your S corp salary isn't qualified business income. A higher salary shrinks the base for the 20% QBI deduction. But medicine, law and accounting are specified service businesses, so in 2026 the QBI deduction phases out anyway once taxable income passes $201,750 ($403,500 joint) and is gone at $276,750 ($553,500 joint). On retirement plans, Solo 401(k) employer contributions are based on W-2 wages, so a very low salary also limits what you can put away. Salary, QBI, retirement contributions and the PTE election belong in the same calculation, reviewed before each filing season.
And the professional corporation?
A PC that doesn't elect S status is a C corporation. It pays 21% federal corporate tax, and dividends are taxed again to the owner. A personal service corporation in health, law or accounting generally must use a calendar year, and its accumulated earnings credit is only $150,000. Most solo doctors and CPAs use a PLLC or PC with an S election. A C corp is worth running the numbers on only if you plan to keep large profits in the company to grow or bring in outside investors.
Next steps
For forming a PLLC in North Carolina, a state-by-state comparison, the QBI thresholds and retirement plans, see our PLLC guide, and for the S corp rules in depth, the S corp election guide. To see whether an S election pays off at your profit level and what salary fits your role, book a free 15-minute call or message WeChat YCLUSA. Actual savings depend on your profit, salary and state taxes.
General tax information, last checked November 19, 2026.
Questions this article answers
Can a PLLC elect S corp status?
Yes. A PLLC that files Form 2553 is taxed as an S corporation, and the IRS treats it as also electing corporate classification, so no Form 8832 is needed. File within 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year it should take effect. Every member must be a U.S. citizen or resident.
What does a multi-member PLLC need to change before electing S status?
An S corp can have only one class of stock, so profit must be distributed by ownership percentage. Partnership-style special allocations and preferred returns have to be changed to pro rata first, with differences in production handled through salary and bonuses, or the election may be at risk.
How should a doctor or CPA set a reasonable salary?
There is no IRS formula. Look at your license and experience, hours, what employed professionals in your specialty and area earn, and how much revenue comes from your own services. In professional practices the salary is usually a larger share of profit than in trading or e-commerce businesses. Document the basis.
What extra does a North Carolina PLLC owe once it elects S status?
It files Form CD-401S and pays franchise tax, minimum $200; a PLLC taxed as a partnership or sole proprietorship does not. It also runs payroll, files Form 941 plus North Carolina withholding and unemployment returns, and issues W-2s.
Ready to talk? The first 15 minutes are on us.
Book online, or send us a few details and we will come back with a written quote within one business day.
