Insights / Individual & family tax

California 1031 Exchanges Into Other States: The Annual FTB 3840, State Clawbacks and Nonresident Withholding

Exchange California property for property in another state and the deferred gain stays California-source: file FTB 3840 every year until it's recognized, then a California nonresident return when you sell. Oregon has a similar OR-24. California buyers withhold 3⅓%, with a 1031 box on Form 593; North Carolina doesn't withhold.

Published By YCL CPA
Questions? Reach us directly

Message us on WhatsApp

Scan the code with WhatsApp, or tap the button if you are on your phone.

919-802-8376Open WhatsApp

Add us on WeChat

Scan the code with WeChat, or copy the WeChat ID and search for it in the app.

WeChat ID: YCLUSA
FacebookInstagramXRednoteWeChat Channels
California 1031 Exchanges Into Other States: The Annual FTB 3840, State Clawbacks and Nonresident Withholding

If you exchange a California rental or investment property for property in Texas, North Carolina or another state, both federal and California tax can be deferred, but California doesn't give up the gain. For taxable years beginning in 2014 or later, California requires anyone who exchanges California property for like-kind property outside the state to file FTB 3840 with the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) for the exchange year and every year after, until the deferred gain is recognized. When you eventually sell the out-of-state property, the California-source portion is taxed by California, even if you left the state long ago. Oregon has a similar annual OR-24.

Why California can still tax the gain

Source: gain on real estate is sourced to the state where the property sits. The appreciation on California property is California-source income.

A 1031 only defers. The gain moved to the new out-of-state property, but the 'California piece' of the appreciation didn't vanish. California's position is that when the deferred gain is eventually recognized, California taxes it, wherever you live at that point.

Hence the tracking. California has no way of seeing an out-of-state sale on its own. FTB 3840 is how you report each year that the deferred gain still exists and where the replacement property is.

FTB 3840: who files, what's reported and for how long

Who: individuals and businesses, residents or not, that exchange California property for like-kind property outside California under section 1031.

When it starts: the taxable year the exchange is completed, for taxable years beginning in 2014 or later.

How long: every year after that, until the California-source deferred gain is recognized on a California return. The form has boxes for initial, amended, annual and final filings.

A later exchange doesn't end it. If the out-of-state replacement is exchanged again, California's tracking continues and the filings go on.

Even with no other California filing obligation. Move to Texas with no California income, and you still file FTB 3840 every year.

If you don't file: the FTB can estimate your income and assess tax, plus penalties and interest.

Several exchanges: file a separate FTB 3840 for each federal exchange.

Example (hypothetical numbers, to show the method)

Mr. Wang lives in California. In 2026 he exchanges a San Jose rental with an $800,000 gain for a rental in Austin, Texas, and in 2027 he moves to Texas.

2026: his federal Form 1040 includes Form 8824 deferring $800,000, and his California Form 540 includes FTB 3840 showing $800,000 of California-source deferred gain.

From 2027: he's a Texas resident with no other California income, but he still files FTB 3840 every year.

2034, he sells the Austin property: federally he recognizes the deferred $800,000 plus later appreciation and recapture. Texas has no individual income tax. The $800,000 of California-source deferred gain goes on a California nonresident return (Form 540NR) and is taxed by California.

If in 2030 he had exchanged Austin for a North Carolina property instead: California's tracking continues and the FTB 3840 filings go on, and appreciation on the North Carolina property is later taxed by North Carolina.

Oregon, Massachusetts and Montana

Oregon: the Oregon Department of Revenue's OR-24 instructions require anyone who exchanges Oregon business or investment property for property outside Oregon to file OR-24 for the exchange year and every year after, until the replacement property is disposed of. On disposition, the Oregon-source deferred gain is reported to Oregon.

Massachusetts and Montana are often listed as having similar clawback rules. We didn't verify the specifics against those states' current rules for this article, so confirm them before exchanging property out of either state.

Other states: most states with an income tax follow the federal 1031 deferral, but the state where the property sits generally keeps the right to tax the gain later. Follow the state revenue department's rules.

State withholding on nonresident sellers

California: on a sale of California real estate, the buyer generally withholds 3⅓% of the sales price (or an elected alternative based on gain) and reports it on Form 593. For a 1031 exchange, the seller checks the simultaneous or deferred like-kind exchange box on Form 593; boot may be subject to withholding, and if the exchange fails, the QI has withholding duties.

North Carolina: no state withholding; the buyer files Form NC-1099NRS for a nonresident seller. Gain on North Carolina property is reported to North Carolina. We haven't seen an annual tracking requirement like California's FTB 3840.

Other states: New York, Maryland, Maine, Oregon, Alabama, Massachusetts and others have withholding or estimated payment rules for nonresident sellers, with different rates and different ways to claim a 1031 exemption. Check before closing and use the state's form to claim an exemption or reduction.

Federal FIRPTA is separate. A foreign seller without a green card also faces 15% federal withholding, which needs its own application on Form 8288-B.

If you plan to move

Moving to a no-tax state doesn't erase California's share. Only post-exchange appreciation, and growth on the out-of-state property itself, follows you to your new home state.

Keep every FTB 3840 and the computations. A sale 10 or 15 years from now will need proof of the California-source deferred gain and the basis through each later exchange.

Installment sales, too: California treats installment sales similarly after you move away, so if you plan to exit through an installment sale, plan for that as well.

Next steps

For 1031 deadlines, boot, depreciation and nonresident rules, see our guide to 1031 exchanges, and for how states tax capital gains, our investment tax guide. We prepare multi-state returns: federal Form 8824, California FTB 3840 and Form 540NR, Oregon OR-24, and North Carolina and other states' returns together. Book a free 15-minute call or message WeChat YCLUSA. Each state's agency has the final word on its rules.

General tax information, last checked November 19, 2026.

Questions this article answers

What do I file if I exchange California property for property in another state?

FTB 3840 with the California Franchise Tax Board for the exchange year and every year after, until the California-source deferred gain is recognized on a California return. That applies whether or not you're a California resident or have other California income, with a separate form for each exchange.

If I move to Texas and sell later, do I still owe California tax?

On the California-source deferred gain, yes. When you sell the out-of-state replacement, the gain deferred from the California property goes on a California nonresident return. Appreciation after the exchange is taxed according to your residence and where the new property is.

What happens if I don't file FTB 3840?

The FTB can estimate your income and assess tax, plus penalties and interest. If the out-of-state property is exchanged again, California's tracking continues, so the annual filings keep going.

Does North Carolina withhold state tax when a nonresident sells property?

No. North Carolina doesn't withhold; the buyer files Form NC-1099NRS for a nonresident seller, and the gain on North Carolina property is reported on a North Carolina return. We haven't seen an annual tracking filing like California's FTB 3840.

Ready to talk? The first 15 minutes are on us.

Book online, or send us a few details and we will come back with a written quote within one business day.

Book a callQuick quote